Fake Polar Bears

Written by Tom on Wednesday, 14 December 2011. Posted in Film, Insights

Polar Bear Cubs

There has been a frenzy of fakery accusations flung at the BBC recently, largely from the Daily Mirror it should be added. The accusations are concerned with how the BBC’s Natural History Unit filmed an enchanting sequence of newly born polar bear cubs suckling their mother. This sequence was actually filmed in a zoo, yet it was intercut with footage of polar bears filmed in the wild.

Whilst this does take some of the legendary mystique away from the filmmakers, it does absolutely nothing to discredit the Frozen Planet series, or the BBC for than matter. Ultimately, the facts do not change; polar bears still have cubs in the wild as they do in a zoo. I challenge anyone who says that it is cheating or misleading, to film that very same scene in the wild (don’t, you’ll be eaten alive). The only reason the different footage was cut together in that sequence was to tell a nice and informative story for viewers, or for an ‘accurate narrative’ as the official line goes.

Yes, as filmmakers ourselves, we may be a bit lenient, but the accusations are quite frankly ridiculous. Us viewers do have some intelligence, and let it be known that we don’t want to have beautiful natural history programmes littered with legal clauses as we sit and view!

Social Bookmarks

About the Author

Tom

Tom

Tom has a degree in Environmental Sciences from the University of East Anglia as well as a Masters in Science Communication from Imperial College London. During his studies he read extensively on communicating environmental issues, and wrote his Masters thesis on communicating sustainability through the medium of film. After his studies, Tom founded Nice and Serious as he passionately believed that film was the most powerful way of engaging our society with the challenges and solutions to the environmental problems we face. Tom also dedicates time to communicating environmental issues to the wider public, having given talks with Ben at the Natural History Museum, the Bank of America and the University of East Anglia.

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.

CancelSubmitting comment...

RSS Feed

Latest Comments

  • ....nice piece Tom and here's hoping it IS part of the global nudge that helps us migrate towards a better way...xTSx
    Tracey Smith

    Tracey Smith

    07. June, 2011|

  • I haven't seen Hugh's show yet as I'm stuck in Oz but a restaurant I went to in Sydney had an interesting take on the whole shark fin...
    Oli

    Oli

    02. February, 2011|